Your Canadian bank will not file Form 3520-A for your TFSA, so the IRS expects you to file a substitute with your Form 3520. Here is how that works and when it is due.
Lou is a tax-preparation tool, not a tax advisor. This article explains how the IRS forms for foreign trusts apply to a TFSA. For advice on your specific situation, work with a qualified tax professional.
The Canada-US tax treaty protects RRSPs and RRIFs on the US side. It says nothing about the TFSA, so the IRS sees a TFSA as an ordinary foreign account that grows tax-free in Canada only.
Why a TFSA can mean trust forms#
The IRS has not issued TFSA-specific guidance. The conservative position, held by most cross-border tax professionals, treats a TFSA as a foreign grantor trust. That brings two forms each year: Form 3520 and Form 3520-A.
Some Canadian plans are exempt. Rev. Proc. 2020-17 lifted these filings for tax-favored foreign plans that exist exclusively or almost exclusively for medical, disability or education benefits, which covers RESPs and RDSPs. A TFSA can be used for anything, so it does not qualify.
For how registered accounts show up on a US return more generally, see RRSP, TFSA, and your US tax return: what to know.
Who files which form#
- Form 3520 is yours. It reports your dealings with the foreign trust: what you put in and what you took out.
- Form 3520-A is the trust's own annual return. In theory the trustee, your Canadian bank, files it. In practice, Canadian banks do not.
When the trust does not file, the Form 3520-A instructions say the US owner must complete a substitute Form 3520-A and attach it to their own Form 3520. Doing so protects you from the penalty for the trust's failure to file, which is the greater of $10,000 or 5% of the account's value.
When they are due#
The dates people quote are often wrong, so here they are from the IRS instructions (Rev. 12-2025):
- Form 3520 is due on the 15th day of the 4th month after your tax year ends: April 15 for most people. If you live and work outside the United States, you have until June 15.
- A substitute Form 3520-A goes in with your Form 3520, so it has the same due date.
- March 15 is the due date only when the trust files its own Form 3520-A, which a Canadian bank will not do for your TFSA.
The EIN line#
Line 1b of Form 3520-A asks for the trust's employer identification number (EIN). The instructions are firm: enter the trust's EIN, never your own SSN or ITIN. Your TFSA does not come with one. The instructions say a trust without an EIN may apply for one, by phone (267-941-1099) if it is based outside the United States.
This rule is not new, but many guides skip it. Ask your tax professional whether to get an EIN for your TFSA before you file.
The FHSA#
The FHSA is in the same position: no treaty protection and no IRS guidance, so the conservative approach treats it as a foreign trust too. See FHSA and your US tax return: what to know.
Where Lou fits#
There is no slip for a TFSA. You tell Lou about the account once (the bank, what you put in, what you took out, and what it earned), and Lou fills Form 3520 and the substitute Form 3520-A for you. Lou leaves the EIN line for you, because only you can get one for the trust.
Lou is a tax-preparation tool, not a tax advisor.