Canadian sales go on Form 8949 and Schedule D. The US uses the cost of the shares you actually sold and the exchange rate on each date, so the US gain is rarely the same as the Canadian one.
Lou is a tax-preparation tool, not a tax advisor. This article explains how Canadian investment sales appear on a US tax return. For advice on your specific situation, work with a qualified tax professional.
If you sell Canadian stocks or other investments in a non-registered account, your broker reports the sale on a T5008. It goes on your Canadian return. As a US person, you report the same sale on your US return.
What the T5008 shows#
A T5008 shows the proceeds of a sale and, usually, its cost (box 20). That cost is your Canadian adjusted cost base (ACB): one average cost across every share of that security you held.
Why the US gain is different#
Two rules make the US gain differ from the Canadian one, and neither is an error.
Which shares you sold. Canada pools all your shares of a company into one average cost. The US uses the cost of the shares you actually sold. Unless you told your broker which shares to sell, the first shares you bought count as the first ones sold. If you bought the same stock more than once, the US cost can be quite different from the T5008 figure.
The exchange rate on each date. The US gain is worked out in US dollars. The cost converts at the exchange rate on the day you bought, and the proceeds at the rate on the day you sold (IRS Publication 54, "Foreign Currency"). The IRS yearly average rate, which you use for most other income, does not apply to sales. A movement in the Canadian dollar alone can turn a Canadian gain into a US loss, or the other way round.
Where the sale goes#
Each sale goes on Form 8949, and the totals carry to Schedule D of Form 1040. Canadian brokers do not issue Form 1099-B, so sales go in the boxes for transactions without one: box C for short-term, box F for long-term.
- Long-term: held more than one year.
- Short-term: held one year or less.
For how other Canadian slips map to US lines, see T4 to 1040: what every American in Canada needs to know.
Canadian mutual funds and ETFs#
Canadian mutual funds and ETFs are generally PFICs (passive foreign investment companies) under US rules, including broad index funds from the big Canadian banks and fund companies. A sale of a PFIC does not follow the normal Schedule D rules: it is reported on Form 8621, and the tax works differently. See Is my Canadian mutual fund or ETF a PFIC?.
The accounts that hold your investments also count toward the FBAR. See FBAR vs Form 8938: what Americans in Canada need to know.
Where Lou fits#
For tax years 2023, 2024 and 2025, Lou reads the T5008 slips you add, on your own device. It lets you enter each purchase you sold from with its own date and cost, converts every sale at the Bank of Canada rate for its dates, and fills Form 8949 and Schedule D. Canadian mutual funds and ETFs are treated as PFICs and prepared on Form 8621.
Nothing is uploaded and there is no account. Lou is free to use until you download the completed forms, with a full refund within 15 days if it does not work for your situation.
Lou is a tax-preparation tool, not a tax advisor.