The FHSA arrived in 2023 and is tax-free in Canada. The Canada-US tax treaty predates it, so the IRS does not recognize the tax-free part. Here is how that works for Americans in Canada.
Lou is a tax-preparation tool, not a tax advisor. This article explains how the IRS treats a Canadian savings account. For advice on your specific situation, work with a qualified tax professional.
The First Home Savings Account is one of the newest registered accounts in Canada. It launched in 2023. It lets Canadian residents save toward a first home, with contributions deducted from income and growth that comes out tax-free.
For Americans in Canada, the US side is not the same.
What the FHSA is in Canada#
The FHSA combines features of an RRSP and a TFSA. Contributions reduce your Canadian taxable income, the money grows without annual Canadian tax, and a qualifying withdrawal for a first home is tax-free. It is a straightforward, popular account, and a lot of younger Canadians are opening one.
Why the IRS sees it differently#
The Canada-US Tax Treaty was last updated in 2007. The FHSA did not exist until 2023. A treaty written before an account exists cannot carry a provision for it, so the FHSA has no treaty protection on the US side. The same gap applies to the TFSA, which arrived in 2009.
This is the heart of the problem for Americans in Canada: the account is tax-free where you live, and reportable where you hold citizenship.
How cross-border professionals treat it#
The IRS has not issued formal guidance on the FHSA. In the absence of guidance, many cross-border tax professionals treat the FHSA the same way they treat a TFSA: as a foreign grantor trust. Under that reading, income earned inside the account is reportable on a US return each year, and the account carries annual trust reporting on Form 3520 and Form 3520-A.
That is the conservative position, not settled law. The treatment could change if the IRS issues guidance. Anyone holding an FHSA with a US filing obligation should confirm their own situation with a qualified professional.
How it compares to your other accounts#
The RRSP is the exception among registered accounts. It has explicit treaty protection, so income inside it can be deferred until withdrawal. The TFSA and the FHSA do not have that protection. A lot of Americans in Canada assume the treaty covers every registered account and are surprised to learn it does not.
For more on how registered accounts appear on a US return, see RRSP, TFSA, and your US tax return: what to know and Roth IRA and TFSA: how the IRS treats each account.
Where Lou fits#
Lou includes Form 3520 and Form 3520-A. If you hold an FHSA and choose to report it as a trust, the annual returns are prepared alongside your Form 1040, with the numbers taken from your Canadian slips rather than typed in by hand.
Lou prepares the forms. You review them. You file.
Lou is a tax-preparation tool, not a tax advisor.