Lou blogBlog

Roth IRA and TFSA: how the IRS treats each account

The Roth IRA and TFSA both offer tax-free growth in their home country. The IRS treats them differently for Americans in Canada.

PublishedNov 11, 2026

If you hold both a Roth IRA and a TFSA, the IRS treats each one differently than you might expect. Here is what that means in practice.

Lou is a tax-preparation tool, not a tax advisor. This article explains how the IRS treats two common tax-advantaged accounts. For advice on your specific situation, work with a qualified tax professional.

The Roth IRA and the TFSA look similar on paper. Both are tax-advantaged savings accounts. Both grow without annual tax on the gains. Both let you withdraw without owing income tax at the time.

The IRS does not treat them the same.

Part I

The Roth IRA#

A Roth IRA is a US domestic account. The IRS created it. Income inside the account grows without annual tax. Qualified withdrawals are tax-free. For Americans in Canada who hold a Roth IRA, there is no additional IRS reporting beyond what appears on your Form 1040. It is exactly what it says it is.

Part II

The TFSA#

A TFSA is a Canadian account. The IRS does not recognize Canada's domestic tax exemption.

Under US rules, income earned inside a TFSA is taxable on a US return in the year it is earned. This catches a lot of Americans in Canada by surprise. The TFSA functions as intended in Canada. The US treatment is different.

Many cross-border tax professionals also treat a TFSA as a foreign trust under IRS rules, which requires annual Form 3520 and Form 3520-A filings alongside your Form 1040 for each year the account exists.

Part III

The RRSP comparison#

An RRSP has explicit treaty protection. The Canada-US Tax Treaty allows income inside an RRSP to be deferred until withdrawal, matching how Canada treats it. The TFSA has no equivalent treaty provision.

A lot of Americans in Canada hold both registered accounts and assume the treaty covers both. The RRSP gets the treaty. The TFSA does not.

For more on how registered accounts appear on a US return, see RRSP, TFSA, and your US tax return: what to know.

Part IV

Where Lou fits#

Lou includes Form 3520 and Form 3520-A. If you hold a TFSA, the annual trust returns are prepared alongside your Form 1040.

Lou prepares the forms. You review them. You file.

Lou is a tax-preparation tool, not a tax advisor.

https://lou.bigtimedesign.ca

More

More from the Lou blog

Already did your Canadian taxes?Let Lou do the US paperwork.

Free to try. $49 CAD plus tax covers your 2023, 2024 and 2025 returns; each new tax year after that is $49. Your documents stay on your device.

Start with Lou · $49